A prospective study undertaken to examine bacterial contamination at p
resentation, frequency and type of antibiotic prescribed, and outcome,
in 50 patients presenting with hand injuries of varying severity, is
reported. Results of a national survey of trends in antibiotic prescri
bing for similar wounds in plastic surgery units are also recorded. Pr
eoperative swabs cultured normal flora or no growth. Forty-eight patie
nts received antibiotics with little consistency in the agent used, ro
ute of administration, or length of treatment. Clinical wound infectio
n occurred in three crush injuries. No significant difference in the n
umbers of surgeons using antibiotics for clean and crushed injuries of
all types was demonstrated. The state of the wound, rather than the t
issue damaged, seemed to dictate antibiotic use. In dirty wounds, howe
ver, damage to deep structures appeared to be an indication for antibi
otics - significantly fewer respondents treated dirty injuries of the
skin alone. The authors believe that antibiotic use in open hand injur
y is of no proven benefit, and that this aspect of hand surgery requir
es further investigation.