P. Barnett et L. Malcolm, BEYOND IDEOLOGY - THE EMERGING ROLES OF NEW-ZEALAND CROWN HEALTH ENTERPRISES, International journal of health services, 27(1), 1997, pp. 89-108
New Zealand has experienced radical public sector restructuring over t
he last decade, including the corporatization and subsequent privatiza
tion of state trading units and the reform of social services, includi
ng health. In 1991 a new government proposed and then implemented more
radical health reforms, which included the corporatization of state-o
wned provider units (23 crown health enterprises) and the creation of
an internal market with purchasers (four regional health authorities)
separated from providers. Interviews with chief executives of crown he
alth enterprises suggest that provider units are seeking a wider role
than envisaged, with an interest in the health needs of their populati
ons and undertaking some purchasing on their behalf. The purchasers se
e a narrower role for crown health enterprises. Both purchasers and pr
oviders report that competition between providers is not particularly
helpful (and with only limited opportunities for this to occur), with
collaboration being seen as more useful. Providers are critical of pur
chasers' ability to adopt a strategic approach. Unlike other aspects o
f New Zealand's restructuring, there appears to be a retreat from some
of the more radical facets of the reforms, reflecting both the resist
ance of the health sector and a newly uncertain political climate.