This article focuses upon the appropriateness of reader-response appro
aches to literature reaching with L2 students. It argues that response
-oriented teaching is the new orthodoxy in LI literature classrooms an
d that, given some necessary and overdue clarification of the concept
of response, similar approaches can operate with older L2 students. Ex
amples of activities with poetry with first year university students a
re discussed in order to show how response-based work can develop disc
iplined procedures that respect both the integrity of the texts and of
the renders. The article concludes with a short list of methodologica
l principles for literature teaching based on the assumption that our
prime responsibility to our students is to help them become critical r
eaders, not literary critics.