This paper describes field measurements and analysis carried out on th
e Elkhart Creek soil-arch culvert structure in British Columbia, Canad
a. The structure has a span of 13.4 m, a rise of 7.3 m, and a soil cov
er of 9.6 m. The original structure collapsed during backfilling in Oc
tober 1987. A new structure of the same design was built in the fall o
f 1989, and because of controversy regarding the design thrust value,
it was instrumented to measure thrust and displacements in the arch. D
isplacements and stresses in the soil were also measured. The measured
thrust values were much lower than expected and indicated that signif
icant positive soil arching occurred, similar to that observed at the
Vieux Comptoir soil-stucture in Quebec in 1975. A nonlinear finite ele
ment analysis of the soil-structure system was carried out simulating
the construction procedures used, and the computed response was compar
ed with the measurements. The computed and observed responses were in
reasonable agreement in all aspects, namely thrust, displacements, and
soil stresses, provided an allowance was made for slip at the bolted
connections.