R. Wassmann et al., 1ST RECORDS OF A FIELD EXPERIMENT ON FERTILIZER EFFECTS ON METHANE EMISSION FROM RICE FIELDS IN HUNAN-PROVINCE (PEOPLES-REPUBLIC-OF-CHINA), Geophysical research letters, 20(19), 1993, pp. 2071-2074
Fertilizer effects on methane emission from Chinese rice fields were i
nvestigated by a praxis-oriented approach applying balanced amendments
of N, P and K. The data set obtained covered the emission rates of ap
p. one month in early rice and one month in late rice 1991. An interco
mparison between the 4 treatments showed pronounced differences in the
magnitudes of methane emission rates. The combined organic/mineral fe
rtilizer application, commonly used as local farming practice, resulte
d in relatively high seasonal averages of methane emission rates (26.5
mg CH4 m-2 h-1 in early rice and 50.1 mg CH4 m-2 h-1 in late rice). T
he lowest emission rates were observed in the plot with pure mineral f
ertilization (6.5 mg CH4 m-2 h-1 in early rice and 14.3 mg CH4 m-2 h-1
in late rice). Pure organic fertilizers by unfermented substances yie
lded the highest methane emission rates of all field trials (38.6 mg C
H4 m-2 h-1 in early rice and 56.2 mg CH4 m-2 h-1 in late rice). The fe
rtilization with fermented material derived from biogas generators res
ulted in substantially lower emission rates than the other trials with
organic amendments, the seasonal averages cor-responded to 15.9 mg CH
4 m-2 h-1 (early rice) and 22.5 mg CH4 m-2 h-1 (late rice). Interpreta
tion of the results can be obtained from the different potentials of t
hese fertilizers for methane production. Based on this concept the dif
ferent methane emission rates observed with organic/mineral, pure mine
ral and pure unfermented-organic fertilizers could directly be attribu
ted to the different quantities of organic matter incorporated into th
e soil. The low methane emission. from the plot treated with fermented
material could be explained by a depletion of potential methane precu
rsors resulting from the preceding fermentation. The results of this i
nvestigation provide evidence that the extensive use of specific chemi
cal fertilizers and the application of sludge from the operation of bi
ogas generators could lead to a net reduction of the methane emission
from rice fields.