INVERSION OF KINETIC AND THERMODYNAMIC PREFERENCES IN MEISENHEIMER COMPLEX-FORMATION - REGIOSELECTIVITY IN THE REACTION OF 2,4,6-TRIMETHYLPHENOXIDE ION WITH 2,4,6-TRINITROANISOLE AND THE IMPORTANCE OF STEREOELECTRONIC FACTORS
Ra. Manderville et E. Buncel, INVERSION OF KINETIC AND THERMODYNAMIC PREFERENCES IN MEISENHEIMER COMPLEX-FORMATION - REGIOSELECTIVITY IN THE REACTION OF 2,4,6-TRIMETHYLPHENOXIDE ION WITH 2,4,6-TRINITROANISOLE AND THE IMPORTANCE OF STEREOELECTRONIC FACTORS, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 115(20), 1993, pp. 8985-8989
To probe regioselectivity in Meisenheimer complexation, the reaction o
f 2,4,6-trimethylphenoxide ion (MesO-) with 2,4,6-trinitroanisole (TNA
) was followed by H-1 and C-13 NMR spectroscopy in the new low-tempera
ture solvent acetonitrile-glyme (1:1, v/v) at -40-degrees-C to ambient
temperatures. The key results include finding a kinetic preference fo
r C-1 attachment and that the sigma-adduct that results from C-3 attac
k is thermodynamically more stable (K1T3 behavior); this behavior is i
n direct contrast to the ''normal'' C-3 to C-1 isomerization pathway d
isplayed by alkoxides and hydroxide with TNA (K3T1 behavior) as well a
s different from the regioselectivity shown by the phenoxide ion as an
O-nucleophile (K1T1 behavior). Stereoelectronic stabilization of C-1
O-adducts through n-sigma interaction of antiperiplanar lone pairs wi
th the requisite C-O acceptor bonds is recognized as a major factor in
the regioselectivity of C-1 versus that of C-3 attack. Such an antipe
riplanar conformer is found to be energetically inaccessible for the C
-1 TNA.OMes- adduct 3, unlike the C-1 TNA.OMe- adduct 4. Estimation of
the kinetic barriers and thermodynamics of adduct formation demonstra
tes the instability of 3 relative to that of 4 and thereby provides a
basis for the slide or metamorphosis of K3T1 to K1T3 behavior.