Dr. Huggins et Wl. Pan, NITROGEN EFFICIENCY COMPONENT ANALYSIS - AN EVALUATION OF CROPPING SYSTEM DIFFERENCES IN PRODUCTIVITY, Agronomy journal, 85(4), 1993, pp. 898-905
The development of cropping systems that use N efficiently requires me
thods that evaluate system differences in N use. A procedure, based co
nceptually on soil and plant processes that affect N use, was develope
d to evaluate differences in N use efficiency among cropping systems.
The method uses measurements of yield, grain N, above ground plant N,
applied N, and postharvest inorganic soil N to partition cropping syst
em differences in yield and grain N into N efficiency components. The
components consist of N supply, available N efficiency, available N up
take efficiency, N utilization efficiency, grain N accumulation effici
ency, and N harvest index. The N efficiency component analysis was dem
onstrated for a field study with bard red spring wheat (Triticum aesti
vum L. 'WB 906R') where conventional tillage had a greater yield and g
rain N than no-tillage. At low N rates, 78% of the difference in yield
between the two was attributed to N supply and available N efficiency
components. At high levels of applied N, 88% of the yield difference
was attributed to the N utilization efficiency component. Differences
in grain N were attributed to N supply and available N efficiency comp
onents, whereas components of grain N accumulation efficiency, availab
le N uptake efficiency, and N harvest index were nonsignificant. Overa
ll, this new approach transcends empirical analyses and provides insig
ht into underlying mechanisms of cropping system differences in N use.