L. Luborsky et al., PSYCHOLOGICAL HEALTH-SICKNESS (PHS) AS A PREDICTOR OF OUTCOMES IN DYNAMIC AND OTHER PSYCHOTHERAPIES, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology, 61(4), 1993, pp. 542-548
This is the first dedicated review of quantitative studies on Sigmund
Freud's proposition that the poorer the psychological health, the more
limited are the benefits from treatment. Since observer-rated scales
for psychological health-sickness were developed in 1949, many studies
have applied them, and the majority show significant prediction of ou
tcomes of psychotherapy, with correlations between .2 and .35. This ar
ticle reviews (a) the main methods of measurement, (b) the record of p
redictive success, (c) validity studies, (d) the relation to psychiatr
ic diagnosis, (e) prediction in forms of treatment other than psychoth
erapy, and (e) theories of why psychological health predicts outcomes
of psychotherapy.