Ga. Biel et Cm. Carswell, MUSICAL NOTATION FOR THE KEYBOARD - AN EXAMINATION OF STIMULUS-RESPONSE COMPATIBILITY, Applied cognitive psychology, 7(5), 1993, pp. 433-452
A recent stimulus-response compatibility model was used to provide a p
erformance evaluation of an experimental notation for the keyboard in
which pitch varies horizontally in visual space. One hundred and twent
y subjects performed a choice reaction time task using either the hori
zontal notation or a more traditional vertical notation. Half the subj
ects in each notation group received white noise and half received pit
ch-varying feedback with responses. A horizontal display advantage was
revealed when rules of the model were applied to data analyses. Furth
er, the horizontal display advantage was not dependent on the nature o
f the feedback. In a second experiment, performance of musicians and n
on-musicians was compared using the horizontal and vertical notations.
Musicians' performance was uniformly better than that of non-musician
s, and did not differ with notation orientation. The findings support
the use of non-traditional horizontal notations for novice performance
on a keyboard instrument.