The photoinitiated [2 + 2] cycloaddition reaction between acrolein and
ethylene is investigated using ab initio molecular orbital calculatio
ns. RHF and UHF geometry optimizations with die 6-31G basis set are r
eported for ethylene, acrolein, triplet acrolein, gauche and trans tri
plet biradical intermediates, and formylcyclobutane, and are used to a
ddress the issues of reactivity and selectivity in enone-olefin photoa
nnulations. In contrast to a model in which regioselectivity arises fr
om the alignment of dipoles in the excited state, calculated dipole mo
ments and electrostatic potentials show no basis for such an assignmen
t. It is striking that the proposed dipole as well as FMO bawd selecti
vity models in the literature used to explain observed product distrib
utions are inadequate, leaving open the question of the mechanistic si
gnificance of a triplet exciplex in determining regioselectivity.