Mj. Kohn et al., O ISOTOPE ZONING IN GARNET AND STAUROLITE - EVIDENCE FOR CLOSED-SYSTEM MINERAL GROWTH DURING REGIONAL METAMORPHISM, The American mineralogist, 78(9-10), 1993, pp. 988-1001
Microanalysis of O isotope ratios has been made in traverses across tw
o garnet crystals and one staurolite sample (all approximately 1 cm in
diameter) from a metapelitic schist and across one garnet sample appr
oximately 4.5 mm in diameter from an amphibolite from the Cordillera D
arwin metamorphic complex, Tierra del Fuego, Chile. The metapelitic sa
mple contains garnet + biotite + staurolite + plagioclase + muscovite
+ quartz + ilmenite + chlorite, and P- T conditions determined from mi
neral rims were approximately 575-degrees-C and 7 kbar. O isotope anal
yses were collected with a spatial resolution of 0.5-1 mm using a lase
r extraction system. The 72 analyses of the two garnet crystals in the
metapelite indicate a gradual increase in deltaO-18 from approximatel
y 3.5 parts per thousand (V-SMOW) in the core to approximately 4.0 par
ts per thousand at the rims. The 70 analyses of the staurolite grain s
how that it is generally unzoned, with an average value of 4.37 +/- 0.
08 parts per thousand (1sigma), except for localized increases in delt
aO-18 toward some parts of the rim; these increases may be the result
of late chlorite alteration. The garnet amphibolite sample contains ga
rnet + biotite + plagioclase + quartz + chlorite + hornblende + cummin
g-tonite, and P-T conditions were approximately 625-degrees-C and 4.5
kbar. The 25 analyses of the garnet sample indicate that it is homogen
eous, with an average isotopic value of 3.44 +/- 0.05 parts per thousa
nd (1sigma), except for three analyses that average 3.26 parts per tho
usand. The 22 analyses of the fine-grained matrix near the garnet indi
cate that the matrix is compositionally nearly homogeneous, with an av
erage value of 3.70 +/- 0.15 parts per thousand (1sigma). With this P-
T-t path, the reaction history, and no infiltration by a fluid with di
sequilibrium deltaO-18, the predicted prograde zonation for the metape
litic garnets is between +0.2 and +0.75 parts per thousand (rim to cor
e), with a best estimate of +0.5%. The zonation for staurolite is appr
oximately -0.05 parts per thousand, and for the amphibolite garnet it
is between -0.01 and +0.06 parts per thousand. The correspondence of t
he predictions and observations suggests that the rocks were not infil
trated by a fluid that is not in isotopic equilibrium during regional
metamorphism. The data show that regional metamorphic garnet and staur
olite can preserve prograde variations of O isotopes in amphibolite fa
cies terranes.