In the reduction of dioxygen to water, proton transfer must be involve
d. Therefore, dioxygen reduction may be regarded as a modified type of
proton transfer reaction. To understand it, the underlying phenomenon
of proton transfer must first be understood. This requires an evaluat
ion of the kinetic models for the proton transfer reaction. After deci
ding which model applies best, the effects of adsorption on proton tra
nsfer in the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) are compared with those
which have been observed experimentally in dioxygen reduction. Both r
eactions in acid media are characterized by volcano relationships. How
ever, the volcano in the HER results from reversible absorption effect
s and that in dioxygen reduction results from irreversible absorption.
The effect of this is to reduce the pre-exponential value in the rate
expression from a figure close to the theoretical values predicted fr
om the model to a value several orders of magnitude lower. The models
of the separate oxygen electrode steps are shown to give excellent agr
eement with experiment in both acid and alkaline solution over a wide
range of materials. The consequences for practical dioxygen reduction
catalysts are discussed.