W. Zimmerli et al., PERSONAL-EXPERIENCE WITH ANTIBIOTIC-PROPH YLAXIS IN ELECTIVE COLON SURGERY - RETROSPECTIVE STUDY, Helvetica chirurgica acta, 60(1-2), 1993, pp. 71-73
We reviewed in a retrospective study all our 616 electively operated c
olons over 15 years from 1976 to 1990 for morbidity and mortality depe
nding the antibiotic prophylaxis. Interventions were performed on 578
patients with a mean age of 65.5 + 13.7 years; in 38 cases there was a
n earlier elective colic operation. The sex ratio was 1.26 men to 1 wo
man. 71.8% of the indications were adenocarcinomas of the colon. All o
ther diagnostics, as well as different types of interventions were inc
luded in the study. All interventions was preceded by large bowel prep
aration. The colic anastomosis were almost always handswen in two laye
rs. Until 1982 systematically, we gave prophylaxis by combination of a
minoglycoside with metronidazole or clindamycine, n = 329 (53.4% of 61
6). We then changed to ceftriaxone, n = 287 (46.6% of 616). Ceftriaxon
e was applicated in single dose (n = 142), in multi doses (n = 71) and
combined in almost all cases with metronidazole (n = 74). We found si
gnificantly better morbidity and mortality results with ceftriaxone th
an in the aminoglycoside combined group: The ceftriaxone group had a s
epticemia or colocutaneous fistulas requiring reoperation incidence of
1.4% (4/287) versus 4.6% (15/329) (p = 0.023). Mortality decreased fr
om 4.9% (16/329) under aminoglycoside combined prophylaxis to 1.74% (5
/287) in the ceftriaxone group (p = 0.033). The infection rate of the
surgical accesses diminished from 13.1% (43/329) to 8% (23/287) under
ceftriaxone (p = 0.043). The frequency of intraabdominal abscesses dec
reased from 7.6% (25/329) to 3.8% (11/287) (p = 0.047). The conservati
vely treated colocutaneous fistulas decreased from 6.7% (22/329) to 3.
1% (9/287) (p = 0.044). The differences of the morbidity and mortality
in the subgroups of the ceftriaxone prophylaxis was not significant.
-We concluded that the antibiotic prophylaxis in the elective surgery
of the colon is sufficient with a 2 g ceftriaxone single dose. For pat
ients at higher risk, occasional combination with metronidazole was us
eful.