The authors are in disagreement with the literature on the results of
patellectomy after comminuted fracture of the patella. They assessed r
etrospectively 17 patients who underwent unilateral total patellectomy
between 1955 and 1980. Subjective and objective (clinical examination
, radiologic examination and Cibex II studies) assessment was carried
out for each patient using the contralateral healthy knee as a control
. The results demonstrated 88% patient satisfaction, no ligamentous in
stability and no early arthrosis but a decrease in extensor muscle str
ength to 75% of normal. The authors conclude that total patellectomy i
s better tolerated and causes less morbidity than suggested in the lit
erature.