In this study, grammatical aspects of telegraphese (written telegram s
tyle) in normal adults are compared to agrammatic narratives in Broca'
s aphasia. The study is conducted in four languages: Dutch, German, Sw
edish, and Finnish. The background for this study is the claim, both f
rom theoreticians and practitioners, that agrammatism can be equated w
ith telegram style in normals. In summary, the comparisons of utteranc
e length, grammaticality, omissions and substitutions of closed class
items, and structures show that despite some superficial parallels the
two registers of telegraphese and agrammatism are qualitatively diffe
rent.