INDIVIDUALIZED CHEMOTHERAPY FOR PATIENTS WITH NONSMALL CELL LUNG-CANCER DETERMINED BY PROSPECTIVE IDENTIFICATION OF NEUROENDOCRINE MARKERS AND IN-VITRO DRUG-SENSITIVITY TESTING
Gl. Shaw et al., INDIVIDUALIZED CHEMOTHERAPY FOR PATIENTS WITH NONSMALL CELL LUNG-CANCER DETERMINED BY PROSPECTIVE IDENTIFICATION OF NEUROENDOCRINE MARKERS AND IN-VITRO DRUG-SENSITIVITY TESTING, Cancer research, 53(21), 1993, pp. 5181-5187
We attempted to prospectively select individualized chemotherapy for 1
65 non-small cell lung cancer patients based on in vitro analysis of n
euroendocrine (NE) markers and drug sensitivity testing (DST) using fr
esh tumor. The chemotherapy used for small cell lung cancer (SCLC) was
selected when NE marker expression determined by L-dopa decarboxylase
assay was documented. Selection of chemotherapy for other patients wa
s guided by DST results using a modified dye exclusion assay when avai
lable; otherwise etoposide and cisplatin was administered. A total of
112 of 165 (68%) specimens were assayed for L-dopa decarboxylase and 3
6 patients (22%) had DST. In vitro data directed management for 27 of
96 (28%) patients given chemotherapy: 6 with NE markers were treated w
ith the SCLC regimen; and 21 (58% of those with DST) received their DS
T-selected chemotherapy regimen. There were no significant differences
in response rate among all 3 treatment arms (P = 0.076). However, res
ponse to chemotherapy for the patients treated prospectively with a SC
LC regimen was 3 of 6 (50%), marginally better than patients given the
ir DST-selected chemotherapy regimen (2 of 21; 9 %; P = 0.056) or thos
e treated with etoposide and cisplatin (10 of 69; 14%; P = 0.061). Whe
n patients whose NE markers were identified retrospectively are includ
ed, 4 of 9 (44%) responded to administered chemotherapy, compared to 7
of 55 (13%) with no NE markers present (P = 0.04). There were no diff
erences in survival among the three treatment groups. Cisplatin and et
oposide comprised the most active regimen in vitro for tumors from 16
of 36 (44%) patients, potentially limiting the benefit of DST since th
is is often the empiric therapy for non-SCLC. Furthermore, the correla
tion between in vitro and clinical response is nonsignificant for all
drugs tested, highlighting the overall relative resistance of non-SCLC
tumors to currently available chemotherapy.