A major problem with alcoholism treatment is the high rate of early re
cidivism to drinking and re-admission for alcoholism treatment. The ob
jective of this study was to retest a model to predict early (within 6
months) re-admission to alcoholism treatment using a second independe
nt sample. Additionally, we compared a high-risk alcoholism relapse (H
AR) model (defined by chronicity of heavy drinking, daily alcohol cons
umption and previous treatment history) with three previously defined
alcoholism typologies for descriptive and predictive validity. Male al
coholics (N = 299) admitted for treatment at a Veterans Affairs inpati
ent treatment program were interviewed and then followed for 6 months
after discharge. The HAR model identified 107 (35.8%) alcoholics at hi
gh-risk for relapse prior to discharge. Of the HAR group 61% were re-a
dmitted within 6 months compared to 28% of the low-risk alcoholism rel
apse (LAR) group (OR = 4.0, 95% CI = 2.4-6.8). The HAR group was older
with a lower socioeconomic status, fewer legal problems, more physica
l and mental health problems and decreased evidence of social support.
The HAR model was more successful than were the typologies for predic
ting early relapse. The HAR model demonstrates descriptive and predict
ive validity and compares favorably to existing typology models.