Two transmutation methods of Cs-137 using a proton accelerator were ev
aluated in terms of the effective half life and the transmutation ener
gy. One was the proton method which mainly used high energy proton spa
llation reaction for transmutation, and the other was the spallation n
eutron method which mainly used thermal neutron capture reaction. The
transmutation energies and the effective half lives for the two transm
utation methods were calculated by Monte Carlo simulation codes for pa
rticle transport, the NMTC/JAERI code and the MCNP code. The calculate
d transmutation energies were 510 MeV and 570 MeV for the spallation n
eutron method and the proton method, respectively, for an effective ha
lf life of 2 yr for Cs-137.