Dmj. Tubbing et al., THE CONTRIBUTION OF COMPLEXED COPPER TO THE METABOLIC INHIBITION OF ALGAE AND BACTERIA IN SYNTHETIC MEDIA AND RIVER WATER, Water research, 28(1), 1994, pp. 37-44
The toxicity of copper is reduced due to complexation by ligands, e.g.
humic acids or synthetic compounds like EDTA. Therefore, the concentr
ation of free metal ions has been considered the main determinant of m
etal toxicity. This early hypothesis was tested by adding different co
ncentrations of copper to water from the River Rhine and to a syntheti
c medium, supplemented with different concentrations of EDTA. Subseque
ntly the following parameters were determined: (1) voltammetrically la
bile copper (differential pulse anodic stripping voltammetry), (2) fra
ction of copper retained on Chelex-100 columns, (3) photosynthetic rat
e of the alga Selenastrum capricornutum (in synthetic medium) and (4)
rate of [H-3]thymidine incorporation by multiplying bacteria (in river
water). Addition of 5 muM Cu to the medium with 5 or 10 muM of EDTA i
nhibited algal photosynthesis, although copper was not voltammetricall
y detectable (<0.005 muM). Small spikes of copper (0.06-1.00 muM) adde
d to river water inhibited the multiplication of bacteria; electrochem
ical determination showed no detectable copper activity at the lower c
oncentrations. Chelex-retained copper correlated well with the percent
age inhibition of the two biological activities. According to calculat
ions using the model TITRATOR copper-EDTA complexes and un-ionized sal
ts (mainly CuCO3) were dominant copper species in synthetic solutions
inhibiting photosynthesis. The GECHEQ model calculated that free coppe
r as well as chelex-labile copper correlated well with the inhibition
of bacterial growth rate. Therefore it seems that complexed copper is
''biologically available'' to a significant extent. Furthermore, inter
mediate labile copper, such as chelex-retained copper, is an appropria
te measure of copper toxicity.