Jc. Amiard et al., INFLUENCE OF SOME ECOLOGICAL AND BIOLOGIC AL FACTORS ON METAL BIOACCUMULATION IN YOUNG OYSTERS (CRASSOSTREA-GIGAS THUNBERG) DURING THEIR SPAT REARING, Water research, 28(1), 1994, pp. 219-231
Introduction Metal bioaccumulation in bivalves may occur as a conseque
nce of the ingestion of inert or living particles which have bound tra
ce elements. The best experiments, such as those carried out by Borcha
rdt (1983, 1985) about Cd in mussels, have shown that suspended matter
is only a small part of the source of contamination in molluscs. But
whatever the reliability of the experimental methodologies, laboratory
conditions never perfectly mimic natural phenomena. Thus, we have pla
nned to restart these works using a large-scale experiment, the proced
ure of which was characterized by a small number of controlled paramet
ers with a high degree of representativeness of reality. During experi
mental nursing of young oysters, we have assessed the influence of dif
ferent controlled quantities of phytoplankton and of various experimen
tal population densities on metal transfer from their environment to m
olluscs. Materials and methods Oysters (Crassostrea gigas) were distri
buted in several cylindrical containers the bottoms of which consisted
of a sieve. Food and seawater were renewed continuously by means of a
n ascending current (Baud and Bacher, 1990). Nursing assays were carri
ed out during summer over a 74 day period or during winter over a 91 d
ay period. Twelve groups of oysters were set up according to food supp
ly (0, 1x, 2x and 4x of Skeletonema costatum grown on underground salt
-water in addition to natural phytoplankton) and population density (2
5,000 or 50,000 individuals per experimental container) (Table 1). You
ng molluscs were fed according to an alternating cycle of 3 h-feeding
periods and 2 h-periods without food. The mean concentrations of pigme
nt cells in the rearing seawater of the molluscs were 0, 10, 20 and 40
mug/l. This seawater was renewed at a flow rate of 3 m3/h during the
summer experiment and 1 or 3 m3/h during winter. At the end of the nur
sing period, molluscs exposed to different experimental conditions wer
e separated using sieves with different mesh-sizes (6, 8, 10, 14 and 1
8 mm; Table 2). Young oysters were purged for 36 h with a view to limi
ting the overvaluation of bioaccumulated metal levels due to ingested
material (Amiard-Triquet et al., 1984; Kennedy, 1986). In each experim
ental and age-related category, 90 individuals were sampled and divide
d into 3 groups of 30 specimens. In these groups, soft tissues were se
parated from the shells and oven-dried at 80-degrees-C for 48 h. The d
ry samples were powdered and three aliquots of about 1 00 mg each were
digested with 1 ml of concentrated nitric acid (HNO3, Suprapur) at 95
-degrees-C for 1 h. Then trace element analyses were performed in this
solution diluted with deionized water by flame (Zn) or flameless (Cd,
Cu, Pb) atomic absorption spectrophotometry using the Zeeman effect (
Amiard et al., 1987). The influence of food supplies, flow rate and ex
perimental population density on the dry weight of the soft tissues of
young oysters, their metal concentrations and body burdens were exami
ned using multi-linear regression analysis (Tomassone et al., 1983; Da
gnelie, 1973). Results and discussion In Table 3 the metal concentrati
ons in the seawater [Table 3(a)], phytoplankton and seston [Table 3(b)
] are shown. In summer, the average weight and metal (Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn)
burden in the soft tissues of the oysters increased with the quantity
of food available and the size of the individuals, whereas it decrease
d concomitantly with increasing density of the experimental population
of oysters (Table 4). The individual weights increased with increasin
g food supply (Fig. 2). The increase of food quantity and of the size
of the oysters was concomitant with enhancement of the weight of their
soft tissues and a decrease of metal concentrations (Table 5). In win
ter, the population density was correlated negatively with the weight
of soft tissues but not with metal concentrations or burdens (Table 6)
. In summer, the experimental population density was correlated with C
u concentration [Table 7 and Fig. 5(B)] but not with Cd, Pb or Zn conc
entrations [Fig. 5(A) and (B)]. The oyster size was correlated negativ
ely with Cd and Pb concentrations during summer [Figs 3 and 5(B)] and
with Cu and Zn concentrations during winter (Fig. 2 and Table 8). The
influence of season was clearly established (Fig. 4): in summer, dry w
eights were two times higher than in winter and Cd, Cu and Zn concentr
ations and body burdens were more elevated in winter whereas the oppos
ite pattern was shown for Pb. The influences of food supply, populatio
n density and individual size on the animal's weight, metal concentrat
ions and corresponding body burdens are summed up in Table 9 for both
the studied seasons. Conclusion Increased food supplies induce a biolo
gical dilution of Cd and Pb in young oysters. These results are in agr
eement with previous data about Cd, Cu, Pb and Zn in different species
(Mackay et al., 1975; Boyden, 1974; Phelps and Hetzel, 1987; Berthet,
1986). Thus from the sanitary point of view, the use of underground s
eawater for algal culture is not at risk since metal concentrations in
molluscs are not enhanced.