Pc. Kearney et al., MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN AQUEOUS-MEDIA - NEW BINDING-STUDIES PROVIDE FURTHER INSIGHTS INTO THE CATION-PI INTERACTION AND RELATED PHENOMENA, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 115(22), 1993, pp. 9907-9919
We describe a large number of binding studies in aqueous media designe
d to provide new insights into noncovalent binding interactions, espec
ially the cation-pi interaction. The studies include 7 different hosts
, over 70 guests, and over 150 new binding constants. In addition to t
he now standard NMR methods, circular dichroism has proven to be an es
pecially useful tool for determining aqueous binding constants. We hav
e found that, in addition to the alkyliminium and tetraalkylammonium g
uests we have studied previously, sulfonium and guanidinium guests als
o show substantial cation-pi effects. Bromination of the host greatly
enhances its binding ability in a general fashion, primarily as a resu
lt of hydrophobic interactions. Addition of methoxy groups did not enh
ance binding, apparently as a result of a collapse of the host into a
conformation that is not suitable for binding. Replacement of two benz
ene rings of the host by furans or thiophenes also did not enhance bin
ding. Ab initio calculations provide a rationalization for this effect
and suggest a clearer model for the cation-pi interaction.