Jh. Gillard et al., PREREGISTRATION HOUSE OFFICERS IN THE THAMES REGIONS - CHANGES IN QUALITY OF TRAINING AFTER 4 YEARS, BMJ. British medical journal, 307(6913), 1993, pp. 1176-1179
Objective-To measure changes in the training and workload of preregist
ration house officers over four years. Design-Postal questionnaire. Se
tting-The Thames health regions. Participants-1049 preregistration hou
se officers. Results-Response rate was 69% (725 replies). The proporti
on of house officers officially on duty > 83 hours a week fell from at
least 42% to 21%, and the proportion officially on duty less-than-or-
equal-to 72 hours rose from no more than 9% to 40%. Adequate guidance
in breaking bad news increased from 25% to 46% (p<0.0001; 95% confiden
ce interval for difference, 16.2% to 25.8%) and guidance in pain contr
ol increased from 36% to 46% (p < 0.01; 5.0% to 15.0%). The number of
house officers attending an induction course increased from 61% to 94%
(p < 0.001; 28.9% to 37.1%). There was no change in the proportion un
able to attend formal educational sessions because of clinical commitm
ents or in levels of satisfaction with consultants' educational superv
ision. The median number of inpatients under house officers' care fell
from 20 to 17, but the numbers of patients clerked in an average week
showed little change. House officers were less satisfied with the cli
nical experience their post provided (proportion dissatisfied rose fro
m 30% to 39%; p<0.01; 4.2% to 13.8%) and less enthusiastic about recom
mending their post to a friend (proportion neutral or not recommending
rose from 30% to 42%, p < 0.0001; 7.9% to 16.9%). Conclusion-Despite
progress in reducing hours of duty and providing induction courses, th
e training that hospitals and consultants provide for house officers i
s still unsatisfactory and inconsistent with the General Medical Counc
il's recommendations.