W. Hanggi et al., CYCLIC GESTAGEN ADDITION (MPA) FOR CONTIN UAL TRANSDERMAL OR PERORAL ESTROGEN SUBSTITUTION IN POSTMENOPAUSE - IN FLUENCE EXERCISED ON SERUM-LIPIDS, Geburtshilfe und Frauenheilkunde, 53(10), 1993, pp. 709-714
Since postmenopause unopposed oestrogen replacement therapy (ERT) incr
eases the incidence of endometrial carcinoma, the addition of a proges
tin in non-hysterectomised women is mandatory for hormonal substitutio
n. On the other hand, progestins have a negative influence on serum li
pids and may thus put in question the benefits of the ERT with regard
to the cardiovascular risk. Progestins lower HDL and increase LDL in a
dose-dependent way according to their chemical structure. In the pres
ent non-randomised study, the influence of a cyclic combined oestrogen
progestin substitution on the serum lipids has been measured. From a
total of 90 apparently healthy postmenopausal patients, 59 received a
transdermal ERT with 17beta-Estradiol (Estraderm(R) TTS 50), whereas 3
1 women obtained a daily dose of 0.625 mg conjugated equine oestrogens
(CE) perorally. Additionally all patients were given 10 mg medroxy-Pr
ogesterone-acetat (MPA) daily during the first 10 days of each month.
After 6 months of therapy, the following changes of serum lipids, expr
essed as percentage of initial values, were measured: total cholestero
l in the transdermal group -2.3 % (n. s.), in the peroral group - 11.8
% (p < 0.00001); triglycerides - 3.7 % (n. s.) resp. +8.6 % (n. s.);
HDL cholesterol + 0.2 % (n. s.) resp. - 1.8 % (n. s.); LDL cholesterol
+ 1.3 % (n. s.) resp. - 14.8 % (p < 0.00001). The calculated antherog
enic indices showed a decrease in the peroral substituted group of - 6
.5 % (n. s.) for the HDL/total cholesterol ratio and - 14,8 % (p < 0.0
02) for the LDL/HDL ratio. In the cyclic combination with MPA peroral
ERT with 0.625 mg CE daily seems superior to the transdermal applicati
on of 50 mcg 17-beta-estradiol in respect of the serum-lipid changes.