Rg. Ziegler et al., MIGRATION PATTERNS AND BREAST-CANCER RISK IN ASIAN-AMERICAN WOMEN, Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 85(22), 1993, pp. 1819-1827
Background: Breast cancer incidence rates have historically been 4-7 t
imes higher in the United States than in China or Japan, although the
reasons remain elusive. When Chinese, Japanese, or Filipino women migr
ate to the United States, breast cancer risk rises over several genera
tions and approaches that among U.S. Whites. Purpose: Our objective wa
s to quantify breast cancer risks associated with the various migratio
n patterns of Asian-American women. Methods: A population-based, case-
control study of breast cancer among women of Chinese, Japanese, and F
ilipino ethnicities, aged 20-55 years, was conducted during 1983-1987
in San Francisco-Oakland, California, Los Angeles, California, and Oah
u, Hawaii. We successfully interviewed 597 case subjects (70% of those
eligible) and 966 control subjects (75%). Results: A sixfold gradient
in breast cancer risk by migration patterns was observed. Asian-Ameri
can women born in the West had a breast cancer risk 60% higher than As
ian-American women born in the East. Among those born in the West, ris
k was determined by whether their grandparents, especially grandmother
s, were born in the East or the West. Asian-American women with three
or four grandparents born in the West had a risk 50% higher than those
with all grandparents born in the East. Among the Asian-American wome
n born in the East, breast cancer risk was determined by whether their
communities prior to migration were rural or urban and by the number
of years subsequently lived in the West. Migrants from urban areas had
a risk 30% higher than migrants from rural areas. Migrants who had li
ved in the West for a decade or longer had a risk 80% higher than more
recent migrants. Risk was unrelated to age at migration for women mig
rating at ages less than 36 years. Ethnic-specific incidence rates of
breast cancer in the migrating generation were clearly elevated above
those in the countries of origin, while rates in Asian-Americans born
in the West approximated the U.S. White rate. Conclusions: Exposure to
Western lifestyles had a substantial impact on breast cancer risk in
Asian migrants to the United States during their lifetime. There was n
o direct evidence of an especially susceptible period, during either m
enarche or early reproductive life. Implications: Because heterogeneit
y in breast cancer in these ethnic populations is similar to that in i
nternational comparisons and because analytic epidemiologic studies of
fer the opportunity to disentangle correlated exposures, this study sh
ould provide new insights into the etiology of breast cancer.