Pa. Marten et al., EVALUATION OF THE RATINGS COMPRISING THE ASSOCIATED SYMPTOM CRITERIONOF DSM-III-R GENERALIZED ANXIETY DISORDER, The Journal of nervous and mental disease, 181(11), 1993, pp. 676-682
In light of ongoing considerations for DSM-IV, the 18 ratings comprisi
ng the associated symptom criterion of DSM-III-R generalized anxiety d
isorder were evaluated. The interrater reliability and endorsement rat
es of each symptom were calculated from interview-based ratings of gen
eralized anxiety disorder patients at four sites (total N = 204). Inte
rrater reliability analyses indicated high agreement for the majority
of the 18 symptoms. Regarding the frequency of symptom endorsement, si
gnificant Spearman correlations range = .69 to .94) revealed marked co
nsistency in the rates of symptom endorsement across the four sites. A
list of ''satisfactory'' symptoms was generated from those meeting ce
rtain reliability and endorsement criteria. Seven symptoms were identi
fied: irritability, restlessness, muscle tension, difficulty concentra
ting, sleep difficulties, feeling keyed up, and easy fatigability. Int
erestingly, all of the above belong to either the motor tension or vig
ilance and scanning clusters of the DSM-III-R associated symptom ratin
gs. In contrast, symptoms belonging to the autonomic hyperactivity clu
ster were endorsed infrequently at all sites. Although additional rese
arch is needed (e.g., examination of the symptoms' discriminant validi
ty), these findings essentially support revising the associated sympto
m criterion of generalized anxiety disorder in accord with option E3 i
n the DSM-IV Options Book.