A field-collected sample of earwigs (Forficula auricularia) showed con
siderable variation and a bimodal distribution in male forceps lengths
. Males could be separated into brachy types (74 %) with small forceps
and macro types with long forceps. Female forceps lengths and the bod
y length distributions of both males and females were unimodal. Staged
encounters between males, matched for body size but of different forc
eps type, demonstrated a significant advantage for macro males in aggr
essive interactions. In experiments with more than one male together w
ith a female, macro type males were able to dislodge and take over fem
ales already in copula. Males of the macro type achieve both a larger
proportion of the copulations and significantly longer copulations. Ex
periments in the laboratory, where virgin females were placed in petri
dishes with males of different types, revealed no difference in laten
cy time to copulation. Neither was there any indication of female choi
ce before copulation in experiments where females could choose between
the two male types.