G. Evans et M. Duffy, BEYOND THE SECTARIAN DIVIDE - THE SOCIAL BASES AND POLITICAL CONSEQUENCES OF NATIONALIST AND UNIONIST PARTY COMPETITION IN NORTHERN-IRELAND, British journal of political science, 27, 1997, pp. 47-81
The Northern Irish party system is plausibly represented as two system
s, in which party competition occurs within nationalist and unionist b
locs. Social and ideological divisions within these blocs constrain pa
rties' electoral strategies and thus facilitate or inhibit cross-commu
nal compromise. Using Northern Irish Social Attitudes data, various ac
counts of these intra-communal divisions are tested and their politica
l implications assessed. Contrary to expectations concerning the effec
ts of cross-communal contact, neighbourhood integration is found to ha
ve no relationship with partisanship although, consistent with politic
al socialization theory, young people on both sides of the divide are
more likely than those who are older to support the more recently intr
oduced parties. Most significantly, however, there are noticeable asym
metries in the patterns of cleavage within the unionist and nationalis
t blocs. Among Protestants, left-right ideology has a far stronger imp
act than constitutional position on patterns of partisanship; and soci
al class has considerably stronger effects than does denomination. Mos
t Protestants, whatever their partisanship, also express strongly unio
nist constitutional preferences. In clear contrast, on the nationalist
side party support is polarized along constitutional lines, there is
no cross-cutting ideological division over economic inequality, and a
majority of Catholics adopt a moderate stance on nationalism. It is ar
gued in consequence, that within the unionist bloc the pattern of intr
a-communal party competition militates against constitutional compromi
se as a solution to 'the troubles', whereas among nationalists the uni
dimensional structure of competition for electoral support and the dis
tribution of attitudes towards the constitutional issue are likely to
have influenced the adoption of compromise strategies by Sinn Fein.