Cl. Comella et al., POLYSOMNOGRAPHIC SLEEP MEASURES IN PARKINSONS-DISEASE PATIENTS WITH TREATMENT-INDUCED HALLUCINATIONS, Annals of neurology, 34(5), 1993, pp. 710-714
Prior studies of sleep in Parkinson's disease (PD) have been compromis
ed by inadequate comparison groups, mixed medication regimens, and abs
ence of quantitative data collection. This is the first study to compa
re polysomnographic sleep measures in PD patients on only dopaminergic
medications with and without hallucinations. We performed two consecu
tive nights of polysomnography in 10 nondepressed, nondemented PD pati
ents, 5 with and 5 without hallucinations. All patients were being tre
ated with carbidopa/levodopa and a dopaminergic agonist only. Hallucin
ators and nonhallucinators were group-matched for age, PD duration, se
verity, and medication doses. Both groups had abnormal sleep records.
In particular, there was a reduction in K-complexes and spindle format
ion, and the frequent occurrence of motor activation during rapid eye
movement (REM) sleep consistent with REM behavior disorder. The halluc
inator group had a significantly lower sleep efficiency (0.25 in hallu
cinators vs 0.61 in nonhallucinators, p = 0.006), a reduced total REM
sleep time (mean total REM sleep time, 3 minutes in hallucinators vs 5
0 in nonhallucinators; p = 0.005), and a reduced REM percentage (mean,
5% in hallucinators vs 20% in nonhallucinators; p = 0.011). This stud
y demonstrates that advanced PD patients treated with dopaminergic age
nts have abnormal sleep patterns and that those with dopaminergic-indu
ced hallucinations have significantly greater REM aberrations than non
hallucinating PD patients.