Accuracy in forecasting expected loss costs may well be the most impor
tant determinant of the ultimate profitability of a cohort of property
-liability insurance policies. The existing literature on claim cost f
orecasting focuses on the selection of the ''best'' forecasting model
or method, discarding information provided by closely ranked alternati
ves. In this article, we emphasize the selection of a ''good'' forecas
t rather than a forecasting model, where goodness is defined using mul
tiple criteria that may be vague or fuzzy. Fuzzy set theory is propose
d as a mechanism for combining forecasts from alternative models using
multiple fuzzy criteria. The fuzzy approach is illustrated using fore
casts of automobile bodily injury liability pure premiums. We conclude
that fuzzy set theory provides an effective method for combining stat
istical and judgmental criteria in actuarial decision making.