NEURONAL SPECIFICATION OF DIRECTION AND DISTANCE DURING REACHING MOVEMENTS IN THE SUPERIOR PRECENTRAL PREMOTOR AREA AND PRIMARY MOTOR CORTEX OF MONKEYS
Qg. Fu et al., NEURONAL SPECIFICATION OF DIRECTION AND DISTANCE DURING REACHING MOVEMENTS IN THE SUPERIOR PRECENTRAL PREMOTOR AREA AND PRIMARY MOTOR CORTEX OF MONKEYS, Journal of neurophysiology, 70(5), 1993, pp. 2097-2116
1. Single-unit neuronal activity was recorded in the primary motor and
superior precentral premotor areas of two rhesus monkeys during an ar
m reaching task. The task involved moving a cursor displayed on a vide
o terminal using a draftsman's armtype manipulandum. From a centrally
located start box the animal was required to move to 1 of 48 target bo
xes at eight different directions (0-360-degrees in 45-degree interval
s) and six distances (1.4-5.4 cm in 0.8-cm increments). Both direction
and distance for the upcoming movement were unpredictable. 2. The act
ivity of 197 arm movement-related cells was recorded and evaluated for
each of the 48 targets. Histological examination showed the cells to
be primarily in the primary motor cortex or in the premotor area aroun
d the superior precentral sulcus. Each cell's discharge was aligned on
movement onset and averaged over five trials for each target. Movemen
t kinematics including hand path velocity were also determined. The ta
sk time was divided into three epochs, a premovement period (PT), a mo
vement period (MT), and total time (TT = PT + MT). For each epoch the
average firing was correlated with the direction and distance of the m
ovement using various regression procedures. 3. An analysis of varianc
e (ANOVA) showed that the majority of neurons were modulated significa
ntly by movement direction in each of the three time periods, PT (73.7
%), MT (68.3%), and TT (78.5%). The relationship of the firing to dire
ction was fit to a cosine tuning function for each significantly modul
ated cell. In 86.3% of the cells the firing was correlated significant
ly with a cosine function of movement direction in TT. A cell's prefer
red direction varied little for different movement distances. The mean
difference in preferred direction for the smallest possible change in
distance (0.8 cm) was 12.8 +/- 11.4-degrees (SD) and 17.1 +/- 14.7-de
grees for the largest change in distance (4.0 cm). 4. Correlation anal
ysis revealed that the activity of the majority of cells was modulated
significantly by distance along at least one direction in each of the
three time periods, PT (46.8%), MT (68.8%), and TT (67.&%). subsequen
tly, a univariate linear regression model was used to quantify a cell'
s discharge as a function of distance. For the regressions of firing w
ith distance with a statistically significant correlation (r>0.8), the
mean slope was 3.59 +/-0.17 spikes.s-1.cm-1 for the total time. The e
xistence of a significant distance modulation was not invariably corre
lated with a cell's preferred movement direction. There was only a sli
ght increase in the likelihood of a significant correlation with dista
nce for movements close to a cell's preferred movement direction. Also
, the average slope for distance was not greater for movements close t
o a cell's preferred direction. 5. A two-way ANOVA was used to test fo
r firing modulation with respect to direction and distance and to exam
ine whether interactions between these tow parameters exist. Significa
nt modulation with either direction, distance, or ''interaction'' betw
een these two parameters occurred in 130 of 153 cells evaluated. The i
nteraction terms in the model are equivalent to target position. Next,
a multivariate regression model was developed to relate the cell's di
scharge with direction and distance. A proportional reduction in error
(PRE) approach was used to define the terms in the model. The six req
uired parameters included distance, a sine and cosine function of dire
ction, and target position. The model yielded a significant fit (P<0.0
5) for 119 of the 130 analyzed cells with a mean R2 of 0.61 +/- 0.18.
6. Cell's responses were analyzed on the basis of the partial R2 obtai
ned for direction, distance, and target position. In 37 cells only the
direction term contributed significantly to the fit and in four cells
only distance was significant. In 78 cells either the partial R2 for
both distance and direction was significant or the partial R2 for targ
et position (interaction terms) was significant. In addition, a tempor
al component to the correlation was observed; the discharge during the
premovement period was more likely to be significantly correlated wit
h direction, whereas the discharge during the movement was correlated
with both direction and distance. 7. A similar multivariate analysis o
f variance was carried out on a subset (n = 34) of randomly selected c
ells. The regression results obtained from single movements were compa
red with the results obtained for the average movements. Although the
analysis based on single trials lowered the R2, the results were simil
ar. 8. On the basis of these results, we propose that both movement di
stance (or a tightly coupled parameter) and movement direction are enc
oded in the discharge of primary motor and superior precentral premoto
r area neurons. Furthermore, for many cells firing was also correlated
with target position. The distance-related modulation needs to be con
sidered within the wider context that several movement parameters can
covary with movement amplitude, including velocity, acceleration, forc
e, and muscle activity. Distance information is not preferentially cou
pled to a cell's preferred direction. In addition, evidence for a temp
oral elaboration of this kinematic information was found. During the p
removement period the firing is correlated preferentially with directi
on. Correlation with distance was greatest during the movement. These
results suggest that some degree of independent processing of distance
and direction occurs.