P. Connolly et al., A STUDY OF THE USE OF RAPID METHODS FOR PRESERVATIVE EFFICACY TESTINGOF PHARMACEUTICALS AND COSMETICS, Journal of Applied Bacteriology, 75(5), 1993, pp. 456-462
Three rapid microbiological methods, impedance, the direct epifluoresc
ence technique (DEFT-MEM) and ATP bioluminescence (ATP-B) were evaluat
ed for their applicability to preservative efficacy testing (PET) of p
harmaceuticals and cosmetics. A good correlation between rapid method
response and total colony counts was obtained for untreated suspension
s of Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Candida albican
s with all three methods but, for Aspergillus niger, with impedance on
ly. For chlorhexidine-treated suspensions of Staph. aureus and C. albi
cans, a good dose-response curve was obtained with impedance, but ATP-
B and DEFT-MEM methods underestimated the kill by the order of 1-6 log
s. From the results of this study it is concluded that impedance offer
s an alternative method to colony counting methods for PET but, at the
ir present level of method development, neither DEFT-MEM nor ATP-B can
be considered as satisfactory.