G. Grode et al., PERCUTANEOUS TRANSTHORACIC FINE-NEEDLE LUNG-BIOPSY WITH 3 DIFFERENT NEEDLES - A RETROSPECTIVE STUDY OF RESULTS AND COMPLICATIONS IN 224 PATIENTS, Respiration, 60(5), 1993, pp. 284-288
During 1986-1990, 307 percutaneous transthoracic fine-needle biopsies
(PTNB) were performed on 224 patients (mean age 63 years, range 27-83)
with three types of needles (Nordenstrom, Vacu-Cut(R) and Franzen). T
he overall sensitivity regarding malignant disease in central and peri
pheral pulmonary lesions was 67.0%. In 71 patients with suspected mali
gnancy and a negative PTNB, the examination was repeated and the sensi
tivity was increased to 79.5%. Each needle had the following sensitivi
ty: Nordenstrom 67.4%, Vacu-Cut 75.7%, Franzen 75.9%. The overall pneu
mothorax frequency was 24.7%, being highest with the Nordenstrom needl
e. Hemoptysis was seen in 5 examinations. In conclusion, the Franzen a
nd Vacu-Cut needles have a significantly higher sensitivity and a lowe
r complication frequency compared to the Nordenstrom needle.