Pa. Schultz et Rp. Messmer, THE NATURE OF MULTIPLE BONDS .1. SIGMA,PI-BONDS VS BENT BONDS, A COMPUTATIONAL SURVEY, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 115(23), 1993, pp. 10925-10937
We examine the nature of multiple bonds within an independent-particle
picture, climbing a hierarchy of approximations to the full generaliz
ed valence bond (GVB) description, the most general wave functions for
which an independent particle interpretation of the bonding is possib
le. We begin with a systematic computational survey of molecules with
multiple bonds, comparing sigma, pi and bent bond descriptions, using
the strongly orthogonal perfect-pairing (SOPP) approximation to the GV
B method. Although in several cases the bent-bond model is energetical
ly favored using SOPP-GVB wave functions, in a number of other cases t
he usually accepted sigma, pi bond description is energetically favore
d. In order to obtain a definitive answer to the long-standing questio
n of the better orbital description of the bonding, we conclude that t
he full GVB theory must be employed without restrictions. We outline a
procedure by which generalized valence bond wave functions can be rig
orously obtained without spin coupling or orbital orthogonality constr
aints and apply it to a sequence of molecules directed toward finding
the best qualitative description of the bonding in multiple bonds: sig
ma, pi bonds or bent bonds? Our calculations lend support to Slater's
and Pauling's sixty-year-old conjectures, finding the bent bond descri
ption energetically superior to the symmetry-restricted sigma, pi bond
representation in the theoretical limit of wave functions able to mea
ningfully address this question.