Nj. Shaw et al., RANDOMIZED TRIAL OF ROUTINE VERSUS SELECTIVE PARALYSIS DURING VENTILATION FOR NEONATAL RESPIRATORY-DISTRESS SYNDROME, Archives of Disease in Childhood, 69(5), 1993, pp. 479-482
The strategy of non-selective nueromuscular paralysis was compared wit
h that of synchronised (fast rate) ventilation and selective paralysis
in infants receiving mechanical ventilation for respiratory distress
syndrome with chronic lung disease as the primary outcome measure. One
hundred and ninety three infants weighing under 2000 g were randomly
allocated to receive either pancuronium during mechanical ventilation
in the acute phase of respiratory distress syndrome (non-selective gro
up) or synchronised ventilation (initial ventilatory rate at or above
that of the infant's) (selective group). Infants in the selective grou
p received pancuronium if they were consistently expiring during the i
nspiratory phase of the ventilator cycle. There was no significant dif
ference between the groups with respect to birth weight, gestation, an
d sex distribution. There was no significant difference between the gr
oup with respect to death (selective 19%, non-selective 16%), pneumoth
orax (selective 14%, non-selective 14%), chronic lung disease (selecti
ve 49%), non-selective 47%), and oxygen dependency at 36 weeks' postme
nstrual age (selective 32%, non-selective 39%). Routine paralysis of v
entilated infants has potential complications that may be avoided by u
sing synchronised ventilation. As the latter is not associated with an
increased incidence of long term respiratory complications, it is con
cluded that it is the optimum strategy of the two for ventilating infa
nts with respiratory distress syndrome.