Two experiments observed performance on a cluster identification task
across a variety of common statistical maps. Stimulus maps displayed m
ortality rates for several diseases and subjects had to identify regio
ns of the map that were perceived to form a cluster of particularly hi
gh (or low) mortality. Subjects marked the perceived centroid of each
cluster, and analyses focused on the dispersion of centroid location a
cross subjects. Under these circumstances, monochrome classed chorople
th maps were found to minimize dispersion, compared to a two opposing
colours scheme, a dot density map, a pie map, and a categorical (hue-b
ased) colour scheme. Maps using a familiar geographical unit (i.e. a U
.S. state) supported better recall of the information than maps using
less familiar and smaller geographical units. The results were found t
o be interpretable within current cognitive theory.