Topological analysis of charge density is presented for cluster models
simulating ionic oxides such as MgO and Al2O3. Use Of the constrained
space orbital variation method for the clusters embedded in different
Madelung fields permits us to develop the energy in various physical
meaningful contributions and establish that our results are not biased
to the ionic description. Although the energy decrease due to charge
donation from the anions to the cation is somehow larger for Al2O3 tha
n for MgO, both Laplacian maps and integration of charge density on th
e topological atomic regions are consistent with an ionic picture of t
he chemical bond in both compounds. Moreover, integrated net charges a
re very close to the full ionic value. In summary, topological analysi
s strongly suggests that these two oxides have to be regarded as essen
tially ionic solids with very small participation of covalent effects.