We assessed the effects of trophic structure on phosphorus (P) recycli
ng by fishes, Chaoborus, and zooplankton in lakes with different food
web configurations. Fishes in a piscivore-dominated system recycled li
ttle P compared to that regenerated by zooplankton and Chaoborus. In a
planktivore-dominated lake, excretion by fishes (especially young of
year) dominated P recycling to algae; Chaoborus and zooplankton recycl
ing was decreased due to intense predation by fishes. The sum of P inc
orporated into primary production and lost to sedimentation in the pis
civore-dominated lake was only 77% of that in the planktivore-dominate
d lake. Our analyses suggest that the 30% greater primary production i
n the planktivore-dominated system may be accounted for by the greater
than 40% increase in estimated P recycling that was directly due to d
ifferences in food web structure. Diel vertical migrations by Chaoboru
s concentrated P excretion in the epilimnion during night hours. In th
e planktivore-dominated system, Chaoborus migrations further affected
spatial dynamics of P recycling by concentrating excreted P in the low
er depths of the epilimnion. Diel vertical migrations by zooplankton h
ad little effect on the spatial and temporal dynamics of P recycling e
xcept to dampen the effects of the Chaoborus migrations.