A previous study using intrapleural administration of surface-modified
amosite asbestos showed a difference in the number of pleural mesothe
liomas induced with C18-hydrocarbon derivatised fibres compared to nat
ive amosite asbestos. The study has been repeated with larger groups o
f animals (30) under specific pathogen free conditions, resulting in a
n increase in the mean animal survival time for both fibre-treated gro
ups. Under these conditions there was no significant difference betwee
n the numbers of pleural mesotheliomas induced by C18 hydrocarbon-modi
fied amosite asbestos and native amosite asbestos. The major differenc
e between the two studies was the mean time to death from tumour of ra
ts exposed to fibres. The C18 amosite treated rats in the first study
may not have had a mean survival time long enough to allow mesotheliom
as to develop.