R. Bourbeau et al., NECK INJURIES AMONG BELTED AND UNBELTED OCCUPANTS OF THE FRONT SEAT OF CARS, The journal of trauma, injury, infection, and critical care, 35(5), 1993, pp. 794-799
This article, part of a recently completed research project on safety
belts, presents results on neck injuries. A total of 3927 injured fron
t-seat occupants (drivers and passengers) involved in two-car crashes
were studied. Among them, 725 sustained neck sprains (ICD-9 code 847.0
); some of them may have sustained other injuries as well. The more se
rious injuries to the cervical spine were more prevalent among the unb
elted occupants. Neck sprains were relatively more numerous among belt
ed occupants compared with unbelted ones, with a relative risk estimat
e of 1.68. Similar results hold also for subsets of the data on differ
ent types of collisions; the relative risks ranged from 1.39 to 2.42.
A log linear model was constructed for the odds ratio (neck sprain vs.
no neck sprain) taking into account the following factors: (1) seatbe
lt use, (2) direction of impact, (3) authorized speed limit, and (4) v
ehicle weight. The resulting relative risk estimate (belted vs. unbelt
ed) became 1.58. The results raise questions about seatbelts and their
protection against neck sprains.