Df. Tomback et al., TREE CLUSTERS AND GROWTH FORM DISTRIBUTION IN PINUS CEMBRA, A BIRD-DISPERSED PINE, Arctic and alpine research, 25(4), 1993, pp. 374-381
Two North American bird-dispersed pines, Pinus albicaulis and Pinus fl
exilis, were previously found to occur in three growth forms: single-t
runk, single genet multi-trunk, and multi-genet tree cluster. The latt
er two forms are morphologically similar and distinguishable only by g
enetic analysis; they are together referred to as ''tree clumps.'' In
the Upper Engadine, Switzerland, we studied Pinus cembra to determine
whether this pine species, which is dispersed by Nucifraga caryocatact
es, also occurs in three growth forms. Examining the relative frequenc
y of single-trunk trees and tree clumps, we surveyed P. cembra in thre
e different forest areas and at elevations ranging from 1810 to 2300 m
. Tree clumps occurred at 19 to 30% of the tree sites and up to 45% of
the seedling sites. We sampled foliage from all trunks of 23 tree clu
mps (2 to 7 trunks per clump, ($) over bar x = 3.4, SD = 1.3) for anal
ysis by starch gel protein electrophoresis at four gene loci: FE, PGI,
PGM-1, and PGM-2. Sixteen of the 23 tree clumps (70%) contained more
than one genet and thus were tree clusters. Extrapolation of this perc
entage suggests that tree clusters occupied from 13 to 21% of the P. c
embra tree sites surveyed. A comparison of genotypes and degree of fus
ion between adjacent trunks in tree clumps confirmed that morphology i
s a poor indicator of growth form.