The recovery of a declining population of Golden Plovers may have been
prevented by high nest predation from Carrion Crows Corvus corone and
Common Gulls Larus canus. In order to test this hypothesis predators
were experimentally removed from Kerloch moor in NE Scotland during 19
86-89. Although the numbers of crows and gulls were significantly redu
ced, no young Golden Plover hatched at Kerloch and breeding numbers co
ntinued to decline. Numbers also declined on a less intensive study ar
ea 50 km further away where predators were not removed and where hatch
ing success was poor (except in 1986). Hatching success of other moorl
and waders was generally higher during the experiment than before it,
but breeding numbers did not increase. The removal of crows and gulls
did not lead to increases in the breeding populations of Golden Plover
s and other waders, although the outcome of the experiment was complic
ated by rising nest predation from foxes Vulpes vulpes which may have
masked any benefits from the removal of other predators.