Gender and dietary saturated fat remain two strong predictors of coron
ary heart disease susceptibility. In a retrospective meta-analysis of
five studies, we analyzed the impact of gender and diet composition on
lipoprotein change, or 'response' (DELTA) in 63 normolipidemic subjec
ts fed two contrasting, metabolically controlled diets. One diet had a
low polyunsaturated to saturated fatty acid ratio (low P:S) and the s
econd, a high P:S ratio in a crossover design. Lipid profile 'responsi
veness' was calculated as the adjusted difference (mg/dl) following ea
ch diet period. Multivariate analysis of variance revealed that trigly
ceride (DELTATG), very low density (DELTAVLDL-C), and high density lip
oprotein cholesterol responses (DELTAHDL-C) were the only statisticall
y significant, gender-specific lipid responders. Difference in low den
sity lipoprotein (LDL-C) response to diet was similar between the sexe
s. Multiple regression analysis identified the independent predictors
of DELTAHDL-C for males and females. In females, the HDL-C lowering wa
s predicted by the percentage increase in polyunsaturated fatty acids,
baseline HDL-C levels and, inversely by DELTATG. The male predictor o
f DELTAHDL-C was diet alone (replacement of saturated fat by dietary p
olyunsaturated fatty acids). Results showed that while normolipidemic
males and females show similar reductions in LDL-C following dietary c
hange, DELTAHDL-C is gender-specific, with females showing a greater f
all in the potentially 'beneficial' HDL-C than males. We conclude that
a diet crossover may be of less benefit to normolipidemic females tha
n to males, due to HDL-C lowering. Gender and diet may both become piv
otal considerations in achieving plasma lipid goals.