Background. According to the Knudson two-mutational-event theory, two
mutations at a genetic locus may be required for the development of so
me cancers. Persons who have inherited a defect in one chromosome and
therefore require only one more mutation for cancer development are at
a higher risk of manifesting cancer at a younger age than persons wit
hout an inherited mutation, who need two acquired ''hits.'' This diffe
rence allows one to distinguish familial and sporadic types of the sam
e malignancy by evaluating age of disease onset. Methods. To study the
role of inheritance in the etiology of familial cutaneous melanoma, c
haracteristics of patients with familial versus nonfamilial melanoma w
ere analyzed according to the Knudson two-mutational-event model. Resu
lts. The familial versus nonfamilial graphs, based on age of diagnosis
, did not support this model. However, there was a statistically signi
ficant earlier age of diagnosis for patients with familial melanoma. M
elanoma thickness was less (i.e., earlier cancer at possibly younger a
ge) for patients with a positive versus a negative family history. Con
versely, linear regression, after adjusting for tumor thickness, showe
d that patients with hereditary melanoma still manifested earlier ages
of diagnosis of melanoma compared with sporadic patients. Conclusions
. Genetic patterns other than the two-step model, additional family-re
lated factors, patient-physician sensitization due to a family history
, or a combination of these factors might explain this age difference.
More complex multistep modeling of the data may be helpful in better
characterizing the genetic patterns of cutaneous melanoma.