Rj. Zotz et al., TRANSTHORACIC AND TRANSESOPHAGEAL ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY TO DIAGNOSE VENTRICULAR SEPTAL RUPTURE - IMPORTANCE OF RIGHT HEART INFARCTION, Coronary artery disease, 4(10), 1993, pp. 911-917
Background: Rapid and accurate diagnosis of ventricular septal rupture
(VSR) remains difficult, and the monitoring of hemodynamic deteriorat
ion is a prerequisite for the institution of adequate therapy. The tim
ing of surgical repair is a matter of controversy. Methods: Transthora
cic, transesophageal, color Doppler, and contrast echocardiography wer
e evaluated in 17 patients with VSR in whom the diagnosis was confirme
d by catheterization, surgery, or necropsy. Results: Routine transthor
acic echocardiography visualized VSR in four out of 17 patients and, w
ith additional views, in 12 out of 17 patients. Color Doppler echocard
iography identified the rupture in 15 out of 16, and contrast echocard
iography in 11 out of 11 patients. VSR was identified using transesoph
ageal echocardiography in six out of nine patients, and using color Do
ppler and contrast echocardiography in all patients. Eight out of 10 p
atients who developed right heart myocardial infarction (RMI) died, wh
ereas all patients without RMI survived (P=0.0070). Similarly, eight o
ut of 10 patients with shock died, whereas all patients without surviv
ed (P= 0.0070). Shock occurred more often in patients with RMI (eight
out of 10) than in patients without (two out of six). All patients wit
h both RMI and shock died, whereas those without both conditions survi
ved (P=0.0002). Conclusion: Modern echocardiography is the method of c
hoice in the diagnosis of VSR. Right ventricular function should be ev
aluated in patients with VSR because patients with RMI are at high ris
k of hemodynamic deterioration, with poor outcome. RMI, visible as abn
ormal wall motion, was identified better with transesophageal than wit
h transthoracic echocardiography.