Apj. Mol et G. Spaargaren, ENVIRONMENT, MODERNITY AND THE RISK-SOCIETY - THE APOCALYPTIC HORIZONOF ENVIRONMENTAL REFORM, International sociology, 8(4), 1993, pp. 431-459
The apocalyptic dimension of the ecological situation seems to emerge
in the present-day environmental debate. But in contrast to the early
seventies, eco-alarmism in its present form seems to reflect growing u
ncertainties and anxieties related to the changing character of late m
odern society, Such uncertainties and anxieties do not only pertain to
high-consequence risks, as exemplified by the Chernobyl accident, but
also to local problems of providing safe drinking water from the tap.
Ulrich Beck's risk-society theory, elaborated by Anthony Giddens, ana
lyses these eco-anxieties against the background of changing condition
s of modernity. Because of its overall pessimistic undertone and its b
asic questioning of the role of science and technology in overcoming a
n eco-catastrophe, the risk-society theory seems to fundamentally cont
radict ecological modernisation theory. In confronting both perspectiv
es, the paper aims to contribute to environmental sociology in three w
ays. First. we try to come to understand the present-day rise of eco-a
larmism. Second, an evaluation is made of the contribution of risk-soc
iety theory in analysing environmental problems and in developing proj
ective realistic utopian models dealing with the environmental crisis
under conditions of late or reflexive modernity. Finally, by bringing
formal sociological theory into environmental sociology, both models c
ontribute to the conceptual development and refinement of the sub-disc
ipline.