H. Hafner et al., A CHAPTER OF SYSTEMATIC SCHIZOPHRENIA RES EARCH - SEARCH FOR CAUSAL EXPLANATIONS OF THE SEX DIFFERENCE IN AGE AT 1ST ONSET, Nervenarzt, 64(11), 1993, pp. 706-716
With the aim of detecting causal processes contributing to the onset o
f schizophrenic symptoms a systematic search strategy was worked out.
One of the few epidemiological findings on schizophrenia consistently
diverging from expected values, the sex difference in age at first adm
ission, was taken as a basis and replicated on data from the Danish an
d the Mannheim case registers by controlling for selection and diagnos
tic artefacts. Danish psychiatrists turned out to have underdiagnosed
schizophrenia to a considerable extent at least in 1976, the year from
which the analysed case-register data dated. After the exclusion of a
lternative explanations, the time when symptoms appeared for the first
time and the first acute episode occurred was determined for a repres
entative sample of 267 first-admitted cases with a diagnosis of non-af
fective functional disorder by using the IRAOS interview designed for
this purpose. At any of the definitions of first onset applied the mea
n age of females was significantly higher than that of males, the diff
erence ranging from 3.2 to 4.1 years. The distribution of onsets acros
s the female life cycle showed a clearly delayed increase at young age
and a second, lower peak of onsets at the age of 45-54, whereas the c
umulative incidence up to the age of 60 years was equal for males and
females. On assessing the plausibility of psychosocial versus biologic
al explanations it was hypothesized that due to the effect of estrogen
s the vulnerability threshold for schizophrenia is raised in females u
ntil the menopause. Animal experiments and postmortem analysis showed
that chronic estrogen applications significantly shortened dopmaine-in
duced behaviour and reduced D2 receptor sensitivity in the brain. The
applicability of this pathophysiological mechanism on human schizophre
nia was tested on acutely schizophrenic females with normal menstrual
cycles. A significant negative correlation was found between measures
of symptomatology and plasma estrogen levels. Apparently, manifestatio
n of schizophrenic symptoms is influenced by a sufficiently sensitive
D2 receptor system in the brain, blocked by neuroleptics and modulated
by estrogens.