Bp. Hay et al., QUANTITATIVE STRUCTURE STABILITY RELATIONSHIP FOR POTASSIUM-ION COMPLEXATION BY CROWN-ETHERS - A MOLECULAR MECHANICS AND AB-INITIO STUDY, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 115(24), 1993, pp. 11158-11164
Molecular mechanics calculations with the MM2 program were used to exa
mine the structures and strain energies 11 hexadentate crown ether lig
ands and their potassium complexes. With the exception of K-O stretchi
ng parameters, all force field parameters for interactions involving t
he potassium ion were obtained by fitting to ab initio potential energ
y surfaces for selected distortions in K-O(Me)2 and K-O(Me)(Et). The K
-O stretching parameters were optimized relative to crystallographic d
ata. Comparison of the molecular mechanics results to experimental log
K values that were available for all 11 crown ethers revealed the com
plex stability to be strongly correlated with the difference in strain
energy between the uncomplexed ligand and its potassium complex. The
results establish that both the K-O length preference and bonding dire
ctionality at the ether oxygen donor atom are important factors in the
determination of complex stability. It is concluded that the failure
to consider the orientation of the ether C-O-C moiety, relative to the
metal ion, is a serious flaw in the size-match selectivity theory.