Ca. Gough et al., CALCULATIONS OF THE RELATIVE FREE-ENERGIES OF AQUEOUS SOLVATION OF SEVERAL FLUOROCARBONS - A TEST OF THE BOND POTENTIAL OF MEAN FORCE CORRECTION, The Journal of chemical physics, 99(11), 1993, pp. 9103-9110
The relative free energies of aqueous solvation of several fluorinated
derivatives of methane were calculated using the free energy perturba
tion (FEP) method. The calculations in general duplicated the experime
ntal free energies with relatively good accuracy, but the calculation
of the bond potential of mean force (bond-PMF) contribution [D. A. Pea
rlman and P. A. Kollman, J. Chem. Phys. 94, 4532 (1991)] was necessary
in order to get the most satisfactory agreement with experiment. In p
articular, it was necessary to use this contribution to obtain even qu
alitatively correct results for the relative free energies of hydratio
n of methane and tetrafluoromethane. The reasons for this are discusse
d in terms of the accurate calculation of the effect of the size of th
e solute. In addition, it is noted that the bond-PMF contribution is i
mportant even for FEP calculations not involving large changes in size
, such as the ethanol to ethane perturbation, if the length of a bond
to a disappearing atom is changed during the perturbation. The relativ
e free energy of aqueous solvation for ethanol and ethane was calculat
ed to demonstrate that if the bond between the oxygen and the hydroxyl
hydrogen being removed is ''shrunken'' during the perturbation withou
t including the bond-PMF correction, the calculated free energy is too
low by approximately 3 kcal/mol.