The bacteriophage R17 coat protein binding site consists of an RNA hai
rpin with a single purine nucleotide bulge in the helical stem. Circul
ar permutation analysis (CPA) was used to examine binding effects caus
ed by a single break in the phosphodiester backbone. This method revea
led that breakage of all but one phosphodiester bond within a well-def
ined binding site substantially reduced the binding affinity. This is
probably due to destabilization of the hairpin structure upon breaking
the ribose phosphates at these positions. One circularly permuted iso
mer with the 5' and 3' ends at the bulged nucleotide bound with wild-t
ype affinity. However, extending the 5' end of this CP isomer greatly
reduces binding, making it unlikely that this circularly permuted bind
ing site will be active when embedded in a larger RNA. CPA also locate
s the 5' and 3' boundaries of protein binding sites on the RNA. The 5'
boundary of the R17 coat protein site as defined by CPA was two nucle
otides shorter (nucleotides -15 to +2) than the previously determined
site (-17 to +2). The smaller binding site was verified by terminal tr
uncation experiments. A minimal-binding fragment (-14 to +2) was synth
esized and was found to bind tightly to the coat protein. The site siz
e determined by 3-ethyl-1-nitrosourea-modification interference was la
rger at the 5' end (-16 to +1), probably due, however, to steric effec
ts of ethylation of phosphate oxygens. Thus, the apparent site size of
a protein binding site is dependent upon the method used.