Pontryagin's maximum principle from optimal control theory is used to
find the optimal allocation of energy between growth and reproduction
when lifespan may be finite and the trade-off between growth and repro
duction is linear. Analyses of the optimal allocation problem to date
have generally yielded 'bang-bang' solutions, i.e. determinate growth:
life-histories in which growth is followed by reproduction, with no i
ntermediate phase of simultaneous reproduction and growth. Here we sho
w that an intermediate strategy (indeterminate growth) can be selected
for if the rates of production and mortality either both increase or
both decrease with increasing body size, this arises as a singular sol
ution to the problem. Our conclusion is that indeterminate growth is o
ptimal in more cases than was previously realized. The relevance of ou
r results to natural situations is discussed.